DINNER FOR SCHMUCKS

Photos courtesy of Paramount Pictures

Paul Rudd attempts to win a contest at the expense of Steve Carell in the comedy DINNER FOR SCHMUCKS.

Rudd’s Tim is a financial analyst striving to climb the corporate ladder. After Tim woos the higher-ups with an innovative pitch, he’s invited by the company founder Lance Fender to a secret dinner for idiots. Everyone invited to the party is to bring their own idiot, with the participants attempting to top one another with the foolish guest of all.

Tim, due in large part to his girlfriend's coaxing, is going to decline the invitation, but then Barry stumbles across his path. Tim hits Barry with his car while Barry is attempting to salvage a dead mouse in the middle of the street. You see Barry isn’t just saving a mouse’s body for preservation, but for presentation. Barry collects dead mice, dresses them up in costumes and poses them in various landscapes. As Tim sees it, his meeting with Barry can’t be mere coincidence.

DINNER FOR SCHMUCKS sounds like a twisted comedy where no one is left unscathed. The contrary is actually true. DINNER FOR SCHMUCKS has it’s occasionally outrageous moment, but more often than not plays it safe comically.

It’s a film that’s more intent on warming the heart than chilling the soul. Considering the source material, a dark French comedy titled THE DINNER GAME, and the prospects for ruthless fun, DINNER FOR SCHMUCKS isn’t a bad film, just a missed opportunity.

There are laughs to be had, particularly the interaction between Tim and Barry. Although Rudd and Carell have worked together before in THE 40-YEAR OLD VIRGIN, DINNER FOR SCHMUCKS is a match made in heaven for the two, pitting Rudd’s sensible, every man nature with Carell’s deadpan, goofball antics. The two’s chemistry is dead-on, I only wish the screenplay would have been equally effective.

The same can be said of the direction, from skillful comic director Jay Roach. Roach’s films, including the AUSTIN POWERS and MEET THE PARENTS franchises, have run the gamut from uncomfortably to outrageously funny. DINNER FOR SCHMUCKS is neither, falling more towards mischievous when malicious is called for.

Grade: C+