SMART PEOPLE

Pictures c ourtesy of Miramax
An intellectual father and daughter are academic successes, but failures in the social scene in the comedy-drama SMART PEOPLE. Dennis Quaid is widowed professor Lawrence Wetherhold, an English professor who is attempting to get his book publicized, and is having as much trouble getting his car out of the impound lot. In the midst of scaling the impound lot’s fence, Lawrence has a minor seizure that lands him in the emergency room. Dr. Janet Hartigan, played by Sarah Jessica Parker, is Lawrence’s physician in the ER, and also an old student of his. He begins seeing Janet, which makes his daughter Vanessa, played by Ellen Page, very agitated.

Many of the characters in SMART PEOPLE operate on their own island. That is to say, they function well on their own, but when it comes to relations with others they become withdrawn, awkward and often angered. Lawrence, Vanessa and Lawrence’s adopted brother Chuck, played by Thomas Haden Church, all provide compelling and intriguing individuals, but when they are called upon to interact with one another, the reality of SMART PEOPLE falls short. Part of the problem comes from the screenplay, penned by Mark Poirer. Poirer’s carefully constructed examination of these individuals only goes so far, establishing their own strengths and deficiencies, but fails when it comes to the quintessential portion of the picture, their relationships. Most of, if not all of these encounters are a tough sell. An attractive and successful doctor falling for an old, overweight, unattractive curmudgeon like Lawrence is quite a stretch, and the storyline between Vanessa and her adoptive uncle attempts to play as dark and edgy, but ends up far closer to awkwardness. SMART PEOPLE is a fairly focused study of fractured individuals, but is as seemingly clueless about social interaction as the characters its attempting to bring together.

Grade: C