Reviews that initially aired on "Now Playing", a film review program on WOCC-TV 3 (Westerville, OH), and other thoughts on current films and cinema.
Wednesday, February 20, 2008
PERSEPOLIS
The life and experiences of an Iranian women post 1979 Iran are detailed in the Oscar nominated, PERSEPOLIS. PERSEPOLIS is nominated for Best Animated Feature at this year’s Academy Awards and follows the life of protagonist Marji, a twenty-something Iranian recollecting back to her upbringing. She recalls basic childhood memories, unique family members and the political uproar surrounding her country.
Make no bones about it PERSEPOLIS believes it’s an important portrait of Iran during the tumultuous decades of the 80’s, 90’s and the new millennium. This self-aware animated feature wears its importance on its sleeve, while delivering a fairly straightforward personal and political drama. Marji is an intelligent, sharp-witted woman who is also very cynical and downbeat. Part of her personality traits are no doubt defined by her rugged encounters in Iran, but are not limited to her experiences. The fact that the central character in a personal, coming-of-age story is ultimately unlikable hurts the central conceit of PERSEPOLIS. Add an anti-American slant, and several tame jokes centered on Marji’s grandmother’s unsupportive bosom, and PERSEPOLIS can be chalked up as an ambitious, but failed exercise in the world of animation. Oscar voters undoubtedly were taken in by the serious nature of the subject matter, but failed to notice that the execution in telling the tale was off.
Grade: C
JUMPER
Grade: D+
Saturday, February 16, 2008
The American (Gangster's) Dream
Frank Lucas lived the American dream. Lucas grew up in the tough streets of New York, served as an apprentice in a profitable trade, put forth the necessary effort, persistence and sacrifice to turn him into a thriving entrepreneur. Unfortunately this business was the drug trade.
Lucas's story is told through the eyes of director Ridley Scott in the gritty, rough and realistic drama AMERICAN GANGSTER. Denzel Washington plays the aforementioned Lucas, a bright-eyed youngster from Manhattan who grew up under the tutelage of drug kingpin Bumpy Johnson. Following Johnson's death, a vacancy opened in Manhattan's drug world, and Lucas took full advantage of the opportunity.
While Lucas was gradually building his business from the ground up, including personal visits to Vietnam to obtain his product, Detective Richie Roberts (Russell Crowe) was having a tough time of his own as one of New York City's finest. Although Roberts struggled with marital honesty, he never strayed from integrity in his profession. On the outs with fellow officers, due to his high moral stature, and inability to turn the other cheek, Roberts found himself in charge of mounting a case against Lucas.
Much of AMERICAN GANGSTER operates with the two acting titans apart from one another. Part of Scott's task is to show the two men in their own worlds, contrast their trades, and then show how each trade mirrors the other in many facets. Lucas is the more interesting of the two, and Scott tackles the drug trade both logistically and sensationally. The day to day grunt work that Lucas often handles helps to display the hard work and good business sense that Lucas exhibited. The sensational side is displayed when Lucas, often times in a calculated manner, must flex his proverbial muscles. As he did in TRAINING DAY, Washington shows that he's as good at being bad as he is playing the hero. Intensity is a strong suit in all of Washington's performances, and again serves him well.
Crowe is also very good, but in a much less showy role. In the midst of a divorce, Roberts is failing in his personal life, specifically with infidelity, but still stays on high moral ground with the force. If Washington's performance demanded intensity, Crowe's demands focus. Much like mathematician John Nash from A BEAUTIFUL MIND, Crowe's Roberts is always adding variables and possibilities to situations that arise, or may arise, concerning his case. Without utilizing dialogue, Crowe is able to convey Roberts' intentions. Watching the wheels churn within Roberts is a credit to Crowe's acting prowess.
After much build-up, suspense and cat and mouse games, AMERICAN GANGSTER finally delivers what everyone has come to see, Washington and Crowe, mono y mono. The exchange between the two is classic, and amounts to one of the more memorable toe to toe confrontations seen in recent cinema. The last great meeting between acting icons I can recall was between Robert DeNiro and Al Pacino in HEAT. Much like that encounter, Washington and Crowe deliver a tenacious and intelligent discussion, revealing their characters motivations, cleverness and persuasiveness.
AMERICAN GANGSTER is an authentic piece of Americana, even if it's one our country would rather forget.
Grade: B
AMERICAN GANGSTER becomes available on DVD and HD DVD on Tuesday, February 19th.
Saturday, February 09, 2008
TOP TEN FILMS OF 2007
#10 - 3:10 TO YUMA
This Western remake is as much a character study as it is a gun-slinging shoot’em up. Christian Bale is a determined rancher dead-set on delivering outlaw Russell Crowe to the gallows. The force of each of their performances is moving, as two men learn who they really are by matching wits against each other.
#9 - BRIDGE TO TERRABITHA
Although marketed as the next CHRONICLES OF NARNIA picture, BRIDGE TO TERABITHA was so much more. Two childhood misfits find refuge in each other’s company and their imagination in this wonderfully realized and authentic adaptation of Katherine Patterson’s novel, Josh Hutcherson and AnnaSohia Robb make charming and likable counterparts who learn how to overcome some of life’s toughest lessons.
#8 - HOT FUZZ
HOT FUZZ was the most fun I had in the theater last year. This British picture is everything GRINDHOUSE had hoped to be and more, an oft-beat and silly tale about a gung-ho cop re-stationed in a supposedly quaint London suburb. Whether you’re looking for a hysterical comedy, an exciting action movie or a silly mystery, HOT FUZZ delivers all three.
#7 - ATONEMENT
The Oscar nominated picture ATONEMENT deserves all of the acolodes it's received. The best crafted and told yarn of the year revolves around a misconception a young girl has regarding her older sister’s boyfriend. Saoirse Ronan is perfect as young Briony Tallis, demonstrating a maturity beyond her years. Spanning several years, and told through the eyes of the film’s antagonist, ATONEMENT makes for a dramatic, mesmerizing and stunningly surprising tragedy.
#6 - GONE BABY GONE
Ben Affleck’s directorial debut is an impressive work, a purposefully morally murky drama set around a young child’s abduction. Ben’s younger brother Casey gives, by-far, his best performance to date as a driven private-eye convinced he’ll make the right choices. There’s no easy ending for GONE BABY GONE, but a difficult and powerful conclusion that leaves the viewer with plenty to think about.
#5 - THERE WILL BE BLOOD
Daniel Day-Lewis gives the performance of a lifetime as turn-of-the-century prospector Daniel Plainview. Day-Lewis’s intensity personifies a man obsessed by greed, power and his hatred towards mankind. Director Paul Thomas Anderson gradually builds the madness brewing within Daniel, and between Daniel and his rival, Eli, a colorful and passionate preacher. Both men are blinded by their selfishness, but nevertheless results in a clash of two titans, with a result that is magnificently troubling.
#4 - ONCE
ONCE redefined movie musicals for a new generation. John Carney’s soulful and romantic drama follows the lives of two starving artists in modern-day Ireland. The spark and charm created by co-stars Glen Hansard and Marketa Irglova is matched only by their musical talents. Both composed and performed the music for ONCE, expertly impassioned songs that reveal all we need to know about the two destined pair.
#3 - JUNO
Maybe the best teen comedy of all-time, JUNO creates a quirky, clever and hilarious world surrounding a unique and impregnated teenager. Screenwriter Diablo Cody scripted the film’s original and funny dialogue, and star Ellen Page delivers it with well-deserved sincerity and sarcasm. Director Jason Reitman finds just the right beat between the films performers, the script and the low-key, but catchy independent songs that connect with the characters emotions.
#2 - THE LIVES OF OTHERS
Last year’s Oscar winner for Best Foreign Language film is a meticulously calculated and fully rendered look into Weisler, a German surveillance officer and the two German artists, one a writer and one an actor, that he is probing. You may think you know where this story is headed, but as Weisler begins to delve more and more into the artists lives he becomes emotionally attached and begins to manipulate the situation. This outstanding drama is an accomplished character study, a nail-biting thriller and a morality tale wrapped around the tense atmosphere of Germany before the fall of the wall.
#1 - LARS AND THE REAL GIRL
And the best film of 2007 is the carefully crafted, well acted and compassionately written original, LARS AND THE REAL GIRL. This gentle tale of a reclusive young man and his anatomically correct doll as his girlfriend sounds like a gimmick, but it’s original conceit is really a clever comedic tool to lure us into a tale of personal redemption and supportive family dynamics. Ryan Gosling’s Lars never veers towards lunacy, and its in large part to due the fine young actor’s calm touch with Lar’s fractured soul. Director Craig Gillespie handles Nancy Oliver’s screenplay with just the right feel, building a realistic and positive depiction of middle-class Midwesterners and Christians. LARS AND THE REAL GIRL left me feeling refreshed not only about the prospects of our country’s heartland, or the inherent goodness abundant in us all, but most of all that one movie could inspire such humor, heart and originality, and that is why LARS AND THE REAL GIRL is my selection for the best film of 2007.
WORST FILMS OF 2007
#10 - HALLOWEEN
Director Rob Zombie continues to make contributions to my annual worst list, and in 2007 he delivered the unremarkable remake HALLOWEEN. It’s hard to improve upon John Carpenter’s horror classic, but Zombie barely puts forth an effort, replacing Carpenter’s perfect timing and tone with raw gore and gruesomeness.
#9 - FACTORY GIRL
Speaking of horrific, FACTORY GIRL was part bio-pic, part party film, but mainly a mess. This rendering of former Warhol, “It” girl Edie Sedgwick didn’t deliver any insight into Sedgwick or Warhol’s world of eccentrics. FACTORY GIRL was rather tame for a purposefully edgy film.
#8 - SMOKIN' ACES
There was nothing hot about SMOKIN’ ACES in the eight spot. This character-actor driven work thinks it’s a lot cleverer and hipper than it actually is. A gang of mobsters attempt to assassinate a Vegas magician before he can testify against them, and the mess that ensues is neither logical, humorous or thrilling.
#7 - CATCH AND RELEASE
Jennifer Garner elicits no empathy and much eye-rolling in CATCH AND RELEASE. Despite losing her fiancé, Garner’s Gray comes off as self-centered and sour, while her love interest played by Timothy Olyphant is uncomfortably cocky. The performances are matched by a screenplay that knows little about grief or loss.
#6 - BUG
BUG is appropriately titled at number six. Not only did the over-the-top performances by Ashley Judd and Michael Shannon bug me, but Tracy Letts screenplay, adapted from her own stage play, veers overboard in its execution of paranoia, schizophrenia and mind control.
#5 - DEATH SENTENCE
Speaking of over-the-top, SAW director James Wan lost all sense of realism, and humanity, in the revenge flick DEATH SENTENCE. Kevin Bacon goes from mild-mannered executive to raging lunatic after losing his son to a murderous gang of thugs. DEATH SENTENCE is so loony it may have played for laughs if it hadn’t been so brutal.
#4 and #3 - GEORGIA RULE and BECAUSE I SAID SO
Two annoying chick-flicks are number four and three with GEORGIA RULE and BECAUSE I SAID SO. A trio of family members from each film goes from grating to unbearable in these misplaced, slice-of-life morality tales. Jane Fonda and Mandy Moore are expectedly bad, but the talented Dianne Keaton and Lindsay Lohan are remarkably irritating. Keaton’s Daphne is a crude, snobby and immature version of Annie Hall, and Lohan’s Rachel is an example of art mimicking life.
#2 - ALPHA DOG
My runner-up for worst of the year is ALPHA DOG. This two-bit rendering of a real-life story plays like a suburban version of pretty boys gone wild. Teen heart throbs Emile Hirsch and Justin Timberlake try to convince us they’re hardcore hoods, but come off as pansies in this tasteless, true story. The film is predictable, off-kilter and offensive, particularly with its inconsiderate and uncompassionate portrayal of the Mazursky family.
#1 - NORBIT
My worst film of the year is the surreally bad, NORBIT. I didn’t think it could get worse for Eddie Murphy following THE ADVENTURES OF PLUTO NASH, but NORBIT has proved me wrong. Murphy and elder-brother and co-writer Charles Murphy deserve all the credit for this debacle. As if playing one mean-spirited character wasn’t bad enough, Murphy plays two, and kicks in an exasperatingly nerdy third character for good measure. Eddie’s performances in NORBIT are the equivalent to nails on a chalk board, but it’s the writing that earns the film the dubious honor at the top of my list. Alarmingly offensive stereotypes, misplaced moral grandstanding and disgustingly descriptive dialogue leave little doubt as to why NORBIT is the worst film in 2007.
2007 HONORABLE MENTIONS
Overall, I thought 2007 brought several good films to the cinema scene, maybe the best crop of films in the last ten or eleven years. Here are some films I thought were worth noting, even if they couldn't creep into my top ten...
Despite contrasting styles of animation and tone, RATATOUILLE and THE SIMPSONS MOVIE were both terrific. RATATOUILLE took animation to the next level, executing brilliant action sequences and subtle humor into a tale of a rat who aspires to be a French chef. As with all Pixar pics, the subtext of RATATOUILLE is as enriching as the dazzling technical aspects. THE SIMPSONS MOVIE’s animation is simplistic, as it is on television, helping to create its own charm and sense of humor. Clever wordplay, a satirical tone and its standard silliness made THE SIMPSONS MOVIE one of the funniest films of the year.
Another of the funniest movies of 2007 was SUPERBAD. Michael Cera and Jonah Hill try to get lucky for the first time during their high school days, but it’s the hilarious Christopher Mintz-Plasse as McLovin who scores the most, both in laughs and the bedroom. In addition to laughs, SUPERBAD is really a sweet study of two best friends who must go about their separate lives.
Sweetness is at the heart of Disney’s ENCHANTED. This wonderful family film hits all the right notes, both musically and thematically, in a tale of an animated princess transported to real-life New York City. Amy Adams gives an Oscar-worthy performance as the naïve, heartwarming and optimistic Princess Giselle.
On the darker side, SWEENEY TODD and NO COUNTRY FOR OLD MEN examine the threatening nature of mankind. Johnny Depp and Helen Bonham Carter elicit moments of both horror and humor in SWEENEY TODD. The talented actors are assisted by Burton’s twisted touch, and a screenplay with a knack for the absurd. NO COUNTRY FOR OLD MEN marks a return for the Coen Brothers, a brilliant examination of our society’s propensity towards violence. Tommy Lee Jones and Josh Brolin are good, but this film belongs to the Coens and Javier Bardem. Bardem’s Anton is one of the most memorable and menacing men to inflict punishment in recent memory.
Two of the best independent films of the year were THE KING OF KONG and THE ORPHANAGE. As a documentary, THE KING OF KONG views an engaging competition between two men attempting to set the world record for the arcade game Donkey Kong. What would seem trivial isn’t, as the films delves into the participants past failures, successes and their hopes and dreams. THE ORPHANAGE is a chilling horror film in the same mold of THE SIXTH SENSE and THE OTHERS. Great tension and anxiety are elicited thanks to director Juan Antonio Bayona’s touch, and an intense and passionate performance from Belen Rueda.
INTO THE WILD was an engaging escape from writer director Sean Penn. This intriguing look into the real-life story of 20-something vagabond Christopher McCandless was both poetic and maddening. Emile Hirsch is outstanding as the lost soul attempting to find freedom, peace and spirituality, and Hal Holbrook is equally effective as a wise, old codger.
And rounding out my honorable mention list is THE BOURNE ULTIMATUM. The third, and presumably final, installment is the best of the three BOURNE films. Director Paul Greengrass’s non-stop action spectacular is truly an edge-of-your-seat thriller, with exhilarating action sequences, dark secrets and a surprising finish.
THE EYE
In comparison to more recent horror fare, THE EYE is refreshing from a plot perspective. The film is more intent on telling a story, and revealing certain points and mysteries instead of mutilating bodies. If it’s technique is rewarding in comparison to the seemingly weekly torture porn flicks, it’s execution is unfortunately not. The screenplay, written by Sebastian Gutierrez and based on the Hong Kong film JIAN GIU, takes an overly long time to establish the fear and horror that Sydney encounters, and an evener longer time in piecing together the mystery. Part of the problem is Alba herself. She brings little conviction, and a very false sense of angst to Sydney’s predicament. The depth of frustration that a person would be feeling under these circumstances is lost in Alba’s performance. The odd relationship she has with her poorly shaved, loose tie-wearing eye specialist also limits the picture. This sub-plot tinkers with a romance, but never does, and creates several awkward moments. In spite of it’s inadequacies, THE EYE still delivers a fairly strong finish. It’s unfortunate that much of the movie was a slog.
Grade: C-
THE SAVAGES
THE SAVAGES is a more sane, reasonable and realistic portrait of a dysfunctional family in comparison to its equally independent counterpart MARGOT AT THE WEDDING. Both study family dynamics, but where MARGOT AT THE WEDDING only saw distaste, frustration and angst, THE SAVAGES finds distaste, frustration, angst and love. In spite of their differences, Wendy and John attempt to find a solution for their father, whom from all intent and purpose, did not find a lot of healthy solutions for his kids. Linney and Hoffman are very good, conveying not only their thoughts, feelings and annoyance with their characters’ paternal situation, but also in attacking their own personal battles. The film was written and directed by Tamara Jenkins, who also wrote and directed THE SLUMS OF BEVERLY HILLS. Although not as wildly funny as SLUMS, THE SAVAGES still retains an authentic and original family make-up, making the characters outcomes much more rewarding.
Grade: B-
THE ORPHANAGE
The careful and creepy touch that director Juan Antonio Bayona uses in THE ORPHANAGE reminds one of the masterful M. Night Shymalan’s work in THE SIXTH SENSE or to a lesser extent, Alejandro Amenabar’s touch to THE OTHERS. The tone, structure and characters are all similar in each of these films, but so are some of the storytelling consistencies, which lend greatly to the suspense, drama and horror. Screen writer Sergio Sanchez employs two games throughout THE ORPHANAGE, both of which add a great deal of tension and anxiety. Imagery is also a strong suit of the film, as masks, dolls and pictures play an integral part in establishing the film’s uneasy atmosphere. If Kidman and Willis were important to THE OTHERS and THE SIXTH SENSE, Spaniard Belen Rueda is crucial to THE ORPHANAGE. Rueda’s Laura is a tenacious mother, hell-bent on saving her boy and preserving her family. Rueda gives a tense and intense performance that is about as good as any from 2007. THE ORPHANAGE is a real find, a suspense-filled horror film that leaves you with chills through the closing credits.
Grade: B+
CLOVERFIELD
The storytelling technique and experimental filmmaking employed by director Matthew Reeves and executive producer JJ Abrams in CLOVERFIELD is an ambitious one, but one which would have been more successful as a short film. The point of view is told directly through the eyes of six young New York adults, and the uneasy camerawork of the goofy Hud. Initially this technique gives CLOVERFIELD a fresh appeal, but even at a short 84-minute run time, the nauseating hand-held camerawork leaves little to be desired. The hand-held approach was quite a risk, especially for a mainstream picture, and when it comes to application, this technique’s blemishes are easily identified. The camerawork is either too rambunctious, leaving the viewer disoriented, or too steady, leaving one to wonder how Hud can be so calm under such dire circumstances. Occasionally the technique works perfectly, giving CLOVERFIELD an authentic and realistic feel. Watching the monster swoop through Manhattan, and an effectively eerie subway scene mark the film’s best moments. CLOVERFIELD is a missed opportunity, and a disappointment from the normally clever Abrams.
Grade: C
JUNO
Some movies operate in their own world, and seem too far removed from reality. JUNO operates in its own world, but contains an immense amount of humor, compassion and cleverness, that in spite of its eccentricities, works on a basic human level. The personality of the picture is manifested in the film’s dialogue, which develops Juno’s world perfectly. As SWINGERS had it’s own original dialogue for 20-somethings in Hollywood, and GOODFELLAS for Brooklyn gangsters, JUNO finds the right wordplay for smart, silly and sassy 16-year old girls. Screenwriter Diablo Cody deserves all the credit for writing the lines, but Page deserves all the credit for making them sound natural, and equally hilarious. Page left a lasting impression in the flawed HARD CANDY, and she does so again as Juno. Her supporting cast is terrific as well. Michael Cera is type cast well as her part-time lover and full time friend, JK Simmons makes an ideal dad and Olivia Thirlby deserves credit for bouncing off Cody’s zingers as Juno’s buddy. Not to be forgotten is director Jason Reitman, who manages to find just the right beat between the films performers, the script and the low-key, but catchy independent songs that connect with the characters emotions. JUNO is an original, funny and smart teenage comedy that is one of 2007’s best films.
Grade: A
SWEENY TODD: THE DEMON BARBER OF FLEET STREET
If there was ever a match made in heaven, its director Tim Burton and the darkly gruesome and tragic SWEENEY TODD. Burton’s films have always been dark, offbeat and funny, so the content, tone and humor of SWEENEY TODD are right up his alley. SWEENEY TODD falls right in the middle of comedy and tragedy, mixing the wry off-setting humor of Burton, the zany antics of co-star Sasha Baron-Cohen and two eerie, humorous and soulful performances by Depp and co-star Helen Bonham-Carter. This is the sixth Burton-directed film for Depp, and fifth for Carter, and it’s no wonder why they’ve been featured in many of his films. Each is appropriately somber eliciting moving musical renditions, yet both are abnormally humorous, bringing plenty comedic moments. Their performances are matched only by Burton’s wonderful eye for the material. He lavishes the use of blood in the picture, not as much for gore as for depicting the destruction of these two troubled individuals who are spilling the final remains of their humanity. SWEENEY TODD is not for the faint of heart, or weak of stomach, but for those who enjoy an original concept, and the wonderfully peculiar talents of Burton, Depp and Carter.
Grade: B+
THE KITE RUNNER
THE KITE RUNNER is an earnest and seemingly honest portrayal of the danger that encompassed Afghanistan just before the Soviet invasion and more recently, during the Taliban’s rule. Although THE KITE RUNNER effectively conveys these times, it is as much concerned in detailing the intimate story between two childhood friends. Much of the film is set during the boys childhood in Afghanistan. This is the heart of the movie, revealing a great deal about the boys’ character and the men they will become. It also successfully outlines the fragile structure between Amir, his father and others connected to their family. Pressure from his father, everyday bullies and general youth angst are weaved expertly by director Marc Forester and screenwriter David Benioff. Both have adapted Khaled Hosseini’s compassionate story into a moving and personal picture.
Grade: B
CHARLIE WILSON'S WAR
CHARLIE WILSON’S WAR has many similarities to Mike Nichols most recent political, dramatic comedy, PRIMARY COLORS. Both are funny and colorful portraits of womanizing politicians, one’s which struggled with their personal lives, but believed strongly in their causes. Another similarity between the two would be the liberties Nichols takes with the historical accounts. PRIMARY COLORS was under attack by the left for its depiction of former president Bill Clinton, and now conservatives are upset with the arguments against the Reagan Administration. I tend to believe both sides have a legitimate beef. That said, CHARLIE WILSON’S WAR is an engaging slice of entertainment. Hanks is wonderfully sleazy and funny in a role that marks a return to his comedic roots, Julia Roberts, as socialite Joanne Herring, is equally effective playing off-type and Hoffman is deliciously salty. Despite being drenched in the political landscape, these three actors liven up the material, and make Aaron Sorkin’s screenplay work.
Grade: B